TikTok Tuesday: handling controversy through content


Over the weekend, a bakery called JL Patisserie went viral after responding to an influencer’s negative review.

If you haven’t seen it yet, give it a quick watch, then let’s break down why it worked so well and what every brand can learn from it.

TikTok logoPlay button

JLPATISSERIE

I will forever dedicate my time and energy to continue to make it right to the people who value my teams hard work and have respected us and supported us since day one. #review #influencer #bakery

♬ original sound - JLPATISSERIE

At the time of writing this email, the video has 60 million views. What could have been a detrimental social post by an "influencer" has turned around to be a great ad and exposure for JL Patisserie.

They walked through the ingredients, the staff, the craft, the community, and their backstory. By the end, you’ve seen the imported Italian flour, the careful folding of croissants and the intention in every step. A simple, low-fi video, filmed by the founder, and two full minutes of behind-the-scenes storytelling got more reach than any traditional 'crisis comms' would get.

Importantly, response-style content like this doesn’t have to be defensive or dramatic. It can be funny, or straightforward. And the bigger the brand, the more interesting it becomes, because it's exactly what we aren't expecting from them (vital farms and CPK come to mind).

Other ways to use response-style videos

This format of video can be effective beyond just responding to 'bad press.'

If someone leaves a glowing review, you can flip the script and stitch it, thanking them, and walk people through why they loved it. “She said our croissants were flakiest she’s ever had...here’s why.” Then cut to the imported flour, the lamination, the overnight proofing, etc.

You can also use response-style videos to answer the basic questions that come up in your business, like pricing or process.

For example, if you sell pricey refurbished rugs, show the audience what it actually takes to get one ready for a buyer: the hours spent driving to estate sales, hauling and cleaning each rug, storing them in temp-controlled rooms to dry, photographing, listing, and delivering. By the end, the price makes sense.

The same goes for creative services. If someone asks why it takes two months to develop a logo or packaging system, pull back the curtain and show the research, competitive analysis, iterations and real-world testing that goes into getting it right.

It's trite to say that 'transparency' matters, but these are just a few examples of how *easy* it has become. People don’t care for the spin, they want to see how things actually come to life.

That's all for today. Let me know if there's any topics or questions you want me to hit in next weeks edition.

-Ashwinn

Consumer Branding + Marketing Insights

Read more from Consumer Branding + Marketing Insights

I was talking to a founder last week about the importance of this idea of "mental availability" and how it relates to branding building, social and content. There’s a great book called How Brands Grow by Byron Sharp. I highly (highly) recommend giving it a read if you’re building a brand because it provides a counter-narrative to a lot of what we like to believe about marketing. The one that stuck with me: loyalty is basically a myth. Even your “best” customers are buying competitors....

This week I want to cover one of the most important ways to tell your story on social: the pinned “story” post. We’re going to cover: 1. What it is 2. Why it matters 3. Examples of good posts 4. How to do thisWhat are pinned posts? For anyone terribly out of the know, platforms like Instagram and TikTok let you pin up to three posts so they always show up at the top of your profile. Most brands either have no pinned posts or just pin their three highest viewed videos. While that’s fine in...

Last week, I sat down with Zain, founder of Zainith Agency, a specialized TikTok Shop agency, to dig into how the platform really works. The conversation wasn’t just for content, it was also a chance for me to learn how my brand can leverage TikTok Shop firsthand. I can’t share every learning here (would be a very long email), but I pulled out a few key questions and takeaways to give you a clearer picture of how TikTok Shop functions, and what you can take away from it. Q: What does my brand...